Are You Meeting the New Email Laws?
by Eric D. McClenon
Running an online business is tough enough without having the rules change on
you in the middle of the game, and that's what is happening with the laws that
govern permission-based email marketing. A flood of new regulations -
worldwide - are burdening legal marketers, while spammers continue their merry
way.
Several of the newsletters I subscribe to are asking their readers to go through
a re-subscription process as a way of meeting these new requirements, and
undoubtedly will lose large numbers of subscribers in the process.
What Laws?
But what are those laws? I haven't seen any newsletter publisher spell them out,
so decided to do a little research and summarize my findings here.
First you should note that there is not one law to deal with, but many laws.
There are new regulations put into place by the UK and the European
Union. The new EU law went into effect on October 31, 2003. Then there are laws
passed by separate states in the U.S., most notably California, but also by
Kansas, Arkansas and others. And of course there is no refuge in saying that you
won't send email ads to Europe or California, since email addresses often don't
betray the location of their holders. There also doesn't seem to be any
likelihood of harmonization of even U.S. law, not to mention international
regulations. And there will most certainly be new laws to come.
So what do these new laws really say, and how can I avoid running afoul of them?
Let me preface my comments by clearly stating that my suggestions should in no
way be construed as legal counsel, but are merely my assessments of the
requirements of these regulations.
The California law, due to become effective on January 1, 2004 appears to pose
the most problems for legal advertisers. It defines spam as email sent without
direct consent or a pre-existing or current business relationship. But don't
jump to the conclusion that your opt-in or double opt-in subscribers
automatically fit that category. Let's look at these two exemptions one at a
time.
Direct Consent
The California definition of direct consent requires that your subscribers have
expressly agreed to receive the kind of email advertisements you will send them.
This means that if you run a joint venture ad for someone else's product,
advertise third party products, or run ad swaps, you need express consent from
your subscribers to receive all these types of ads, if you want to meet the
California law. Most ezine publishers (and Internet marketers in general) haven'
t received that degree of approval from their subscribers.
Even though 90% of your ezine may be informative articles, if its purpose is to
advertise or promote, it falls under the law. And unquestionably, a solo ad fits
the category also.
But you can't assume that asking your subscribers to agree to receive all these
types of ads leaves you clear when it comes to third party solo ads. This is
because the definition of "direct consent" also requires approval to receive
commercial email advertisements from a specific advertiser. I know this sounds
bizarre, but we're talking California here! To meet this requirement, it appears
that you will need to email a notice of advertisement linked to your solo ad,
rather than the ad itself, or at least remove yourself from the role of
advertiser by appropriate disclaimers accompanying the ad.
Business Relationship
The exemption for preexisting or current business relationships is a bit more
straightforward. It applies to those who have inquired about your products or
services and provided their email address, or have made application concerning
or purchase of your products.
The language of this provision of the law suggests a possible approach to the
whole problem for ezine publishers. That is to make your subscribers "apply" to
receive your ezine. On the application form, you would clearly state what they
would be receiving, and as part of the process, require them to specifically
agree to receive the types of advertisements noted above.
Departing from California law, there is also a requirement to provide a
toll-free number or an unsubscribe email address for opt-outs (thank you, Kansas
and Arkansas!). Strictly speaking, the unsubscribe link at the bottom of your
autoresponder messages doesn't meet this requirement.
Protecting Yourself
So what should you do to avoid being defined a spammer by laws such
California's? Here are my suggestions, again not to be construed as legal
counsel or advice!
1) For ezine publishers, change your subscription process to an application
form, clearly stating the kind of ads you will be sending, and requiring them to
click an "I Agree" type button. This type of process effectively eliminates the
necessity of a double opt-in. Make sure your subscription records are backed up,
offsite. And one more thing. Make sure your subscription acknowledgement
contains no advertisements! I just modified my subscriber welcome message to
refer subscribers to my web site for further information, where I have placed
some new-subscriber special offers.
Also, include an email address subscribers can use to unsubscribe, in addition
to the unsubscribe link that should accompany all your email messages.
What about your existing subscribers? Either require them to go through a new
application-type process as described above, or change to online publishing
only. Note, however, that even online-publishing only may not be totally free of
hazards. That is because some interpretations of the law construe even your
notice of publication to be a form of advertising, if in fact your online
newsletter carries ads. However, I am inclined to believe your liability risks
are small if you merely invite your subscribers to read your online ezine, and
don't include any advertising in the notice itself.
2) For other types of email advertising not part of an ezine, make sure you have
received unambiguous requests to send the kind of advertisements you will be
promoting.
This may mean something like sending inquirers to your website where they click
an "I Agree" button regarding your relationship as advertiser, before you
actually send them any advertisements. I realize this extra step would put you
at a disadvantage relative to others who do not do so, but I predict you will
see this approach or a similar one become more common as the meaning of these
new laws becomes better known. And as sure as night follows day, some California
residents will try out the new law by crying "Spam" regarding someone's ad they
didn't specifically agree to receive. Don't wait for someone in California to
choose your ad for a test case! And again, keep good records to prove the
relationship you have with all who receive your ads.
Include both unsubscribe links and unsubscribe email addresses with each ad. To
help avoid spam complaints even when you have approval to send ads, segregate
your lists so that you send ads only to the people you know are interested in
that kind of product.
I can't claim to have exhaustively presented the issues here, but wanted to give
you a brief summary of what I have learned, so that you can get a grasp on the
issues involved, and seek legal counsel as appropriate for your situation. This
is an evolving environment, of course, so I will try to keep you informed when I
learn about new legislation.
If you want to read more, go to:
California's Anti-Spam Legislation at
http://www.learnsteps4profit.com/antispamca.html UK Anti-Spam Regulations at
http://www.learnsteps4profit.com/antispamuk.html and a fine article on this topic at
http://www.learnsteps4profit.com/antispam.html Glenn Gordon
The Ultimate Autoresponder Guide at
http://www.allaboutautoresponders.info BusinessBuilder Newsletter at
http://www.businessbuildernewsletter.com This article contains 1267 words and may be freely reproduced as long as the
resource information above is included.
| DISCLAIMER: The content provided in this article is not warranted or guaranteed by Developer Shed, Inc. The content provided is intended for entertainment and/or educational purposes in order to introduce to the reader key ideas, concepts, and/or product reviews. As such it is incumbent upon the reader to employ real-world tactics for security and implementation of best practices. We are not liable for any negative consequences that may result from implementing any information covered in our articles or tutorials. If this is a hardware review, it is not recommended to open and/or modify your hardware. |
More Newsletter Marketing Articles
More By Developer Shed
 developerWorks - FREE Tools!
|
You'll get answers to many questions and more from David Barnes, Lead Evangelist for IBM Emerging Internet Technologies. David will discuss aspects of Web 2.0 that bring value to corporations, academia, and government. He'll also discuss IBM's vision around Web 2.0, including the importance of remixability and consumability. The discussion will culminate with examples of various IBM Software Group solutions you can use to get ahead of the Web 2.0 adoption curve.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
As businesses grow increasingly dependent upon Web applications to provide services to customers, employees and partners, these complex applications become more difficult to secure. Although traditional security solutions protect Internet infrastructure layers, they do not guard against HTTP and HTML attacks. Many organizations that conduct security testing still deploy applications that allow attackers to manipulate their logic and wreak havoc on their business. To mitigate this risk, development and delivery teams must address Web application security throughout the lifecycle, addressing the many layers detailed in this paper.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Building a software-as-a-service solution requires addressing a few key technical challenges. In this webcast, we'll focus on the role of IBM Tivoli Directory Server and WebSphere Portlet Factory in creating a Software as a Service solution. We will demonstrate how to use Tivoli Directory Server to prevent the user population of one tenant from accessing the virtual portal and portlet components of another tenant. We will also use the dynamic profile capability of WebSphere Portlet Factory to create multiple highly customized applications from one code base.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Learn to enable users to both rate existing animations and to combine existing animations into new snippets. This is the third in a series of three tutorials that chronicle the building of a site that enables collaborative discussion and animation building using Domino and OpenLaszlo.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Visit IBM developerWorks to download a free trial version of IBM Rational Business Developer V7.1. Rational Business Developer offers rapid and simplified development of business applications and services through Enterprise Generation Language (EGL) tools, generating Java or mainframe solutions while shielding developers from technical complexities.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Ken Krugler, co-founder of code search company Krugle, and Laura Merling, vice president of Marketing and Business Development for Krugle, join to talk about the ins and outs of code search and what it means as a new feature for developerWorks users.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Portfolio Management is about effectively managing portfolio value by aligning portfolio investments with business goals. This complimentary e-kit provides a collection of materials that can help you understand how IBM Rational enables and automates best practices for improved governance and clear visibility into portfolio and project performance across the entire IT project lifecycle.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Join this webcast to discover the key requirements for successful change and release management. Learn how to extend your .NET environment to improve productivity and collaboration, and address core problems afflicting team development. In this webcast, we’ll review typical challenges faced by customers and how to resolve them with the IBM Rational Change and Release Management solution, including Rational ClearCase, Rational ClearQuest and Rational Build Forge. Replay is available for 9 months.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Get a free trial download of the latest version of IBM Rational Performance Tester V7.0.1, a load and performance testing solution for teams concerned about the scalability of their Web-based applications. Combining multiple ease-of-use features with granular detail, Rational Performance Tester simplifies the test-creation, load-generation and data-collection processes that help teams ensure the ability of their applications to accommodate required user loads.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
You can now evaluate IBM Rational Asset Manager V7.0 online without installing or configuring it on your own system! Rational Asset Manager helps create, modify, govern, find, and reuse any type of development assets, including SOA and systems development assets. Rational Asset Manager helps you reduce software development costs and improve quality by facilitating the reuse of all types of software development-related assets. Visit developerWorks to learn more about this product and register to explore its capabilities online.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
All FREE IBM® developerWorks Tools!
|
